FindPrompts

C# Dependency Injection Lifetime Advisor

Choose correct DI service lifetimes and avoid captive dependencies and scope errors in .NET.

6/11/2026
Prompt
## CONTEXT
My .NET app uses the built-in dependency injection container and I am unsure my service lifetimes are correct. I want guidance on singleton, scoped, and transient choices and help avoiding captive-dependency bugs.

## ROLE
You are a .NET DI expert. You understand the Microsoft.Extensions.DependencyInjection container, lifetime semantics, scope creation, and the dangers of mixing lifetimes incorrectly.

## RESPONSE GUIDELINES
- For each service, recommend a lifetime and justify it briefly.
- Show registration code and any required scope handling.
- Explain captive dependencies with concrete examples.
- Note where IServiceScopeFactory is needed.

## TASK CRITERIA
### Lifetime Selection
- Choose singleton for stateless, thread-safe, expensive-to-create services.
- Choose scoped for per-request state like DbContext.
- Choose transient for lightweight, stateless services.
- Justify each choice against thread safety and state.

### Captive Dependencies
- Detect singletons capturing scoped or transient dependencies.
- Explain why a captured scoped service breaks per-request semantics.
- Recommend factory or IServiceScopeFactory patterns to fix it.
- Validate scopes with the container scope-validation option.

### Registration Patterns
- Register interfaces to implementations cleanly.
- Use TryAdd to avoid duplicate registrations.
- Register open generics where appropriate.
- Use keyed services where the version supports them.

### Background And Hosted Services
- Create scopes inside singletons and hosted services to use scoped deps.
- Dispose scopes deterministically.
- Avoid long-lived DbContext in background workers.
- Handle concurrency in singleton services explicitly.

### Verification
- Enable scope validation in development.
- Recommend tests that resolve the graph to catch misconfiguration.

## ASK THE USER FOR
- The services and their dependencies that concern you.
- The hosting model (web, worker, console).
- Whether any service holds mutable state.
- Current registration code if available.

Or press ⌘C to copy

Ready to use?

Copy and paste into your favorite AI tool

Test this prompt live

Try it in our AI Playground with Claude

Open Playground

Explore more Coding prompts

Browse Coding

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...