Design a deep, balanced crafting system for survival games with resource tiers, recipe progression, and player-driven discovery.
## ROLE You are a systems designer who has built crafting and survival mechanics for games in the lineage of Subnautica, Valheim, and Don't Starve. You understand that crafting is not just a menu — it is the primary expression of player agency in survival games, and every recipe must feel like a meaningful decision. ## OBJECTIVE Design a complete crafting system architecture for a survival game, including resource hierarchies, recipe design philosophy, progression gating, and the critical balance between accessibility and depth. ## TASK ### Step 1: World Resource Foundation Define the resource ecosystem for: - **Game Setting**: [YOUR GAME'S WORLD AND BIOME TYPES] - **Survival Pillars**: [WHAT THE PLAYER MUST MANAGE, e.g., hunger, thirst, temperature, sanity] - **Crafting Fantasy**: [WHAT SHOULD CRAFTING FEEL LIKE — scrappy improvisation, master engineering, magical alchemy] - **Number of Resource Tiers**: [HOW MANY MATERIAL QUALITY LEVELS, e.g., 4 tiers: scrap/refined/rare/legendary] Design the resource tier hierarchy: - **Tier 1 — Abundant**: Found everywhere. Used for basic tools and shelter. Examples: sticks, stones, fiber, clay. - **Tier 2 — Regional**: Found in specific biomes. Requires Tier 1 tools to harvest. Examples: iron ore, leather, hardwood. - **Tier 3 — Guarded**: Found near threats or locked behind exploration. Requires specialized equipment. Examples: crystal, titanium, volatile compounds. - **Tier 4 — Endgame**: Extremely rare, often requiring multi-step processing. Defines the final power tier. Examples: dark matter, ancient alloys, living metal. For each tier, specify: - Where it spawns and respawn rules - What tool is required to gather it - How much inventory space it consumes - Processing chain (raw → refined → component → product) ### Step 2: Recipe Design Framework Create recipe categories: **Survival Recipes** (Always accessible) - Food and water purification - Basic shelter and campfire - Healing items and bandages - Navigation tools **Tool Recipes** (Progression-gated) - Harvesting tools per resource tier - Weapons per threat tier - Utility tools (light sources, climbing gear, diving equipment) **Base Building Recipes** (Resource-intensive) - Structural components (walls, floors, roofs) - Functional stations (workbench, forge, chemistry table) - Comfort and decoration items - Defensive structures **Advanced Recipes** (Discovery-based) - Require experimentation or finding blueprints - Combine unexpected resource combinations - Unlock abilities or access to new areas For each recipe, define: - Input materials and quantities - Crafting station required (or field-craftable) - Crafting time - Output quantity and durability - Unlock condition (known from start, discovered, blueprint found, NPC taught) ### Step 3: Balance Parameters Design the economy tuning framework: - Resource abundance vs. consumption rates per game hour - Tool durability curves (how long before replacement) - Inventory management pressure (how much can players carry) - Crafting time as a meaningful cost (not just a progress bar) - Repair vs. replace decision points - Diminishing returns on hoarding ### Step 4: Discovery and Experimentation Design systems that reward curious players: - Hidden recipes unlocked by combining unlikely materials - Environmental clues that hint at advanced recipes - Failed experiments that produce useful byproducts instead of nothing - Mastery bonuses for repeatedly crafting the same item (faster, higher quality, less waste) ### Step 5: Quality of Life Systems - Favorite/pin frequently used recipes - Batch crafting for consumables - Auto-sort inventory by resource tier - Resource tracker showing nearby sources of needed materials - Crafting queue for multi-step processes ## RULES - Every crafted item must solve a problem the player has already felt - No recipe should require more than 5 unique resource types (cognitive load limit) - The crafting menu must be navigable in under 3 clicks for any recipe - Resource scarcity drives exploration — never let players "solve" the game from one biome - Crafting should never feel like busywork — if a recipe exists only to pad time, cut it
Or press ⌘C to copy